The journal

Video Games

What to Ask Before Your Child Plays a Video Game

Games are not films with a controller attached. They ask the player to do things, which makes the questions we bring to them different.

The Discern Editorial Team · 30 September 2026

A film asks you to watch. A game asks you to act. That single difference reshapes the entire conversation about content, because a player is not a spectator receiving a story but a participant producing one. The player pulls the trigger, chooses the cruelty, spends the hours grinding toward a goal the designers set.

Which means the questions we bring to games cannot simply be borrowed from film reviews.

What is the game asking me to do with my hands?

This is the most important question and the one ratings boards handle worst. A game may contain no graphic gore and still ask a child to spend forty hours enjoying cruelty as a mechanic. Another may depict violence in a stylised, almost bloodless way but frame it entirely as burden and loss.

The verbs matter. Protect, build, explore, solve, endure, mourn: these shape a player differently from torture, humiliate, slaughter, dominate. Watch ten minutes of someone playing and write down the verbs.

What does the loop reward?

Every game has a loop: the action you repeat. Grinding for currency, chasing a rank, collecting cosmetics, completing a battle pass. The loop is the real curriculum, because it is what your child will spend most of their hours doing and thinking about when they are not playing.

Ask what the loop makes them feel: capable, patient, curious, or perpetually behind and needing to spend. A loop built on scarcity and comparison teaches something about the self that no cutscene can undo.

Who else is in the room?

Multiplayer changes the content of a game more than any patch note. The strangers on voice chat, the guild that expects attendance, the friend group that shifts to a different title next month. Ask who your child is actually playing with, and whether the social world around the game is one you would invite into your home.

How does it end, and does it?

Games are built to continue. Many have no ending at all, only an endless season of new content. That is a business model, not a moral failure, but it is worth knowing what you are agreeing to when you say yes. A title with a real conclusion gives a child the experience of finishing something, which is its own quiet lesson.

The question behind the questions

Finally, ask what the game is teaching your child to want. Mastery, beauty, companionship, escape, dominance? Games are unusually good at making desires feel natural. Name them, and you have done the work that a rating label cannot do for you.

Put it to work

See how we apply this to a specific title

Every entry in the catalogue carries the same four-part analysis, so you can read the reasoning before your family watches, reads or plays.

Browse the catalogue

Every story teaches a view of the world. We name what it is teaching, so you can decide what your family watches, reads and plays.

Scripture-rooted · AI-assisted · Community-reviewedA tool for discernment, not a substitute for Scripture or pastoral counsel.